Long exposure FWHM varies dramatically from short exposure and Pixinsight SFS measurements

A place to report problems and bugs in SharpCap
Forum rules
‍

If you have a problem or question, please check the FAQ to see if it already has an answer : https://www.sharpcap.co.uk/sharpcap-faqs

Please also read about Troubleshooting USB Issues before posting.

*** Please do not post license keys - please report any problems with licensing to 'admin' by private message ***

Please include the following details in any bug report:

* Version of SharpCap
* Camera and other hardware being user
* Operating system version
* Contents of the SharpCap log after the problem has occurred.
[If SharpCap crashes, please send the bug report when prompted instead of including the log]
Anthony Quintile
Posts: 29
Joined: Wed Dec 02, 2020 7:45 pm

Long exposure FWHM varies dramatically from short exposure and Pixinsight SFS measurements

#1

Post by Anthony Quintile »

I recently updated to the most recent version of Sharpcap.

Although there has always been some disparity between what Sharpcap calculates for subframe FWHMs versus what Subframe Selector measurements calculate in Pixinsight, the difference is much more dramatic now. Also, there is dramatic disparity between FWHM on short exposures for focusing in Sharpcap and those for longer exposure (180 seconds) subframes. Additionally, although this is somewhat subjective, my guiding results and third-party forecasts don't reflect abnormally bad seeing conditions, (nor does the final PI measurements as stated above).

The past few nights, I am getting FWHM values while focusing in Sharpcap (4 second exposures) of around 3.5 px/3.5 arcsec/px. (Image scale is 1.03"/px).

For subframes (180 seconds) the FWHM values calculated by Sharpcap are around 2px/2" greater, in the mid 5s.

Pixinsight SFS measurements for the same data show around 3.5" median value for 180 second subframes.

I am not sure how Sharpcap is calculating FWHM, but maybe it is influenced by the brightness of the stars or something? (longer exposure=brighter stars in the subframe).

I can get my head around it, but the high FWHM numbers are a bit unnerving and it makes it more difficult to determine whether or not the seeing is too rough to keep imaging or not.

Maybe I am doing something wrong or missing something?

Please let me know-

Anthony Quintile
Anthony Quintile
Posts: 29
Joined: Wed Dec 02, 2020 7:45 pm

Re: Long exposure FWHM varies dramatically from short exposure and Pixinsight SFS measurements

#2

Post by Anthony Quintile »

I realize that this may not be a "bug" per se. If I need to submit logs let me know, but I don't know that they're relevant in this case.
User avatar
admin
Site Admin
Posts: 17573
Joined: Sat Feb 11, 2017 3:52 pm
Location: Vale of the White Horse, UK
Contact:

Re: Long exposure FWHM varies dramatically from short exposure and Pixinsight SFS measurements

#3

Post by admin »

Hi,

SharpCap does exclude stars that are fully or very nearly saturated from the FWHM measurement (if the star has saturated pixels then we don't know exactly what the 'M' maximum pixel value really is, so you can't properly measure FWHM). However, the biggest single cause of odd FWHM values is difficulty measuring the background brightness of the image near to the star - if the background is under estimated then the FWHM will measure higher than it should, over-estimation leads to the opposite. This effect is largest when faint stars are are being measured, since the background uncertainty is larger relative to the brightness of the star. Often you can get a more accurate measurement by reducing the star detection sensitivity so that fewer faint stars are being used as part of the measurement.

The main goal of measuring star FWHM in SharpCap is to provide a relative measure so that you can compare the quality of two frames either to check for seeing fluctuations, or during focusing, etc. For this purpose, the exact numerical value of the FWHM doesn't really matter so much, just that it moves in the right direction when focus or seeing change. That being said, if the value remains very different from other measurements once you have tweaked the settings to restrict to brighter stars, I would like to take a look at one or two frames just to see if I can understand why.

thanks,

Robin
Anthony Quintile
Posts: 29
Joined: Wed Dec 02, 2020 7:45 pm

Re: Long exposure FWHM varies dramatically from short exposure and Pixinsight SFS measurements

#4

Post by Anthony Quintile »

I'll go dig around, but where do I find the star detection sensitivity for Live Stacking FWHM Filter screen?

Is it the "Sensitivity" setting in the Multi star FWHM focus dialogue box? Or is there another place to set that for Live Stacking's FWHM Filter dialogue box?

I probably set that pretty high when previously using an OAG on an SCT. Currently I am using a 60mm f4.6 guide scope which shows a lot more stars than the OAG.

What is the default setting for "Sensitivity"?

Thanks for the info...

-Anthony
Anthony Quintile
Posts: 29
Joined: Wed Dec 02, 2020 7:45 pm

Re: Long exposure FWHM varies dramatically from short exposure and Pixinsight SFS measurements

#5

Post by Anthony Quintile »

Realizing now the OAG part is irrelevant, but the SCT part is. Was having a hard time finding enough stars to focus on with the SCT, set sensitivity higher...
User avatar
admin
Site Admin
Posts: 17573
Joined: Sat Feb 11, 2017 3:52 pm
Location: Vale of the White Horse, UK
Contact:

Re: Long exposure FWHM varies dramatically from short exposure and Pixinsight SFS measurements

#6

Post by admin »

Hi,

you need to look in the 'Alignment' tab in live stacking (because the stars are primarily detected to align the frames, being able to measure the FWHM is a secondary thing). The default value is 75, or you can just use the 'Reset All' button on that tab to reset the star detection settings to default.

Another useful thing on that tab is the ability to highlight the stars that are being detected - this lets you check that you are detecting proper stars, not galaxies, hot pixels, etc.

cheers,

Robin
Anthony Quintile
Posts: 29
Joined: Wed Dec 02, 2020 7:45 pm

Re: Long exposure FWHM varies dramatically from short exposure and Pixinsight SFS measurements

#7

Post by Anthony Quintile »

OK, I'll try this out and report back if it doesn't seem to have an effect. I suspect it will.

Thank you!

Anthony
ja2003
Posts: 13
Joined: Mon Jan 09, 2023 7:53 pm

Re: Long exposure FWHM varies dramatically from short exposure and Pixinsight SFS measurements

#8

Post by ja2003 »

Hi Robin
I am finding exactly the same issue - getting sub 4 FWHM using a 2.5 second exposure with 400 gain for the focussing routine and then much larger FWHM scores when live stacking and being embedded in the fits header. Using SharpCap 4.1.14310.0 10/07/2026

Eg: frame_20006.fits FWHM embedded score is 7.27 with a 300 second exposure and gain of 119. Astro Pixel Processor reports star FWHM min max (abs -- rel) 3.96 4.89 -- 3.96 4.89

Eg frame_30003.fits FWHM embedded score is 7.53 with a 300 second exposure and gain of 119. APP gives min max (abs -- rel) 4.49 5.01 -- 4.49 5.00

I find this very frustrating because I monitor the FWHM scores when live stacking to determine if I need to refocus during an imaging run. With such high reported scores I am constantly tempted to stop live stacking and refocus.... only to find that the focussing FWHM is acceptable and the final processed image is fine, but I have "wasted" time which could have allowed me to capture extra subs.

There is a second issue I would like to bring up.... I have remounted my Explore Scientific 127mm with 0.7 x Reducer/corrector and ZWO ASI294MC-Pro camera. When I start the focussing routine - multi star FWHM - if no Region of interest box is showing then the routine reports "no stars" found. I have to put on a region of interest box just slightly smaller than the full screen and then the focussing routine reports a number of stars and I can start trying to find the best focus point. I am sure that this did not happen in previous versions.
Hope you can help solve both issues

I would attach the files but they are both Fits files of 22.3 MB each. If you would like to see both files then please could you specify an alternative upload route.
Many thanks
regards
Julian
User avatar
admin
Site Admin
Posts: 17573
Joined: Sat Feb 11, 2017 3:52 pm
Location: Vale of the White Horse, UK
Contact:

Re: Long exposure FWHM varies dramatically from short exposure and Pixinsight SFS measurements

#9

Post by admin »

Hi,

as a starting point, can you try out the latest SharpCap 4.2 beta version and see how that does - I did find some ways that the two values can be brought closer together, and although they won't be exactly identical they should now be improved.

If that is still giving significant issues then I will happily have a look at your images to see if I can see any further ways to improve - the best way to send them is to upload them to a file sharing platform (like Dropbox, Google Drive, etc) then send the sharing link to me (you can use the 'contact us' email link at the bottom of the forum page if you don't want to post the links here in the forums.

cheers,

Robin
ja2003
Posts: 13
Joined: Mon Jan 09, 2023 7:53 pm

Re: Long exposure FWHM varies dramatically from short exposure and Pixinsight SFS measurements

#10

Post by ja2003 »

Thanks Robin
I will try the 4.2 Beta - when the next clear night comes along.
In the meantime I have uploaded the two files and shared the folder with [email protected]
Regards
Julian
Post Reply