What’s the difference between capturing frames via the start capture button and capturing raw frames directly from camera while live stacking?
Am trying to determine why i get no color in my stars at bin 2x2 when capturing raw frames direct from camera whilst live stacking
Start capture vs capture raw frames
-
archer1960
- Posts: 98
- Joined: Sun Feb 23, 2025 9:04 pm
Re: Start capture vs capture raw frames
With most cameras, binning loses colors because all pixels and their subpixels are combined together. To keep color, the camera would have to combine the red, green and blue pixels separately and then reassemble a pixel from that data.
- admin
- Site Admin
- Posts: 17571
- Joined: Sat Feb 11, 2017 3:52 pm
- Location: Vale of the White Horse, UK
- Contact:
Re: Start capture vs capture raw frames
Hi,
to answer the capturing question, when you just press 'start capture', you get the frame that comes from the camera with any of the processing steps (dark, flat, etc) specified in the 'Preprocessing' controls on the right applied.
When you are live stacking and capture the RAW frames while live stacking, you get the data straight from the camera - no preprocessing applied to what is saved in that case. (Not 100% true any more - in SharpCap 4.2 you can choose to have either processed or unprocessed or both saved while live stacking).
Why like that? Well, if you are just capturing, presumably you chose to use a dark or flat or some other pre-processing option while capturing for a reason, so the processing is applied to the saved images. On the other hand, if you are live stacking, you are using a dark or flat to get a better live stack image, and you might want to re-process the whole lot completely from scratch in another application later, so untouched frames are saved.
As mentioned elsewhere, whether you get mono when binning in a colour camera is *highly* dependent on the make of camera.
What I will also remind you of is that saved images in RAW modes *look* mono if viewed with standard image viewing applications. This is because RAW images (binned or unbinned) store the individual pixel values of the different red, green and blue pixels on the camera sensor. The image will look monochrome, but show a chessboard like grid pattern when viewed at the pixel level (and with enough stretch to make things grey, not black). This is perfectly normal, and just indicates that you need to 'debayer' the image in an appropriate image viewing or processing tool to see the colour.
cheers,
Robin
to answer the capturing question, when you just press 'start capture', you get the frame that comes from the camera with any of the processing steps (dark, flat, etc) specified in the 'Preprocessing' controls on the right applied.
When you are live stacking and capture the RAW frames while live stacking, you get the data straight from the camera - no preprocessing applied to what is saved in that case. (Not 100% true any more - in SharpCap 4.2 you can choose to have either processed or unprocessed or both saved while live stacking).
Why like that? Well, if you are just capturing, presumably you chose to use a dark or flat or some other pre-processing option while capturing for a reason, so the processing is applied to the saved images. On the other hand, if you are live stacking, you are using a dark or flat to get a better live stack image, and you might want to re-process the whole lot completely from scratch in another application later, so untouched frames are saved.
As mentioned elsewhere, whether you get mono when binning in a colour camera is *highly* dependent on the make of camera.
What I will also remind you of is that saved images in RAW modes *look* mono if viewed with standard image viewing applications. This is because RAW images (binned or unbinned) store the individual pixel values of the different red, green and blue pixels on the camera sensor. The image will look monochrome, but show a chessboard like grid pattern when viewed at the pixel level (and with enough stretch to make things grey, not black). This is perfectly normal, and just indicates that you need to 'debayer' the image in an appropriate image viewing or processing tool to see the colour.
cheers,
Robin