GOTO's UPDATE WHAT?
GOTO's UPDATE WHAT?
Not sure what went wrong,but things went wrong for sure. Now things are strange for sure.
I normally skip a few updates as SharpCap goes. I have always gone to the site downloaded the newest version (WINDOWS 64 ). Install it myself.
It always works just fine after the install. This time I fired up SC and it asked me if I wanted to update to the newest version. It had never asked me before so I let it do so. When it was finished I lost all my settings and catalog files and camera information , everything flats and all. It was starting from scratch. All the little settings one must do for your set up I had to do. Each night I have found things I had not set up again or clicked on the box to activate and so on. Now that was bad enough. I do nothing but EAA on Night Skies Network.
I was lucky enough to have others on line with me who went through settings with me as a stare and compare. One sent me catalogs I was missing , Sharpe less objects and LDN and such. I had some also. So you'd think I had it all back and working. Here comes the strange part.
Things seem to be working BUT !! BIG BUT here.
My goto's do not work for deep sky objects. It goes to the object and completes the plate solve. Sadly the object is never in the center it is always off some place . Still on the screen and I can see it but not in the center as it has been always before this update. Lets make it even more strange now. Deep sky objects it will not center, however if I pick a star any star and go to that star it is always in the center. Dead center every time.
I have tested the plate solve and it passed every time. I have plate solved and synced to the mount and it passed every time. Yet even with that and it saying the plate solve passed the object is not centered.
I have stared and compared my settings to others and we are the same as should be and have been for a long time.
What would make it center stars and not deep sky objects?
I normally skip a few updates as SharpCap goes. I have always gone to the site downloaded the newest version (WINDOWS 64 ). Install it myself.
It always works just fine after the install. This time I fired up SC and it asked me if I wanted to update to the newest version. It had never asked me before so I let it do so. When it was finished I lost all my settings and catalog files and camera information , everything flats and all. It was starting from scratch. All the little settings one must do for your set up I had to do. Each night I have found things I had not set up again or clicked on the box to activate and so on. Now that was bad enough. I do nothing but EAA on Night Skies Network.
I was lucky enough to have others on line with me who went through settings with me as a stare and compare. One sent me catalogs I was missing , Sharpe less objects and LDN and such. I had some also. So you'd think I had it all back and working. Here comes the strange part.
Things seem to be working BUT !! BIG BUT here.
My goto's do not work for deep sky objects. It goes to the object and completes the plate solve. Sadly the object is never in the center it is always off some place . Still on the screen and I can see it but not in the center as it has been always before this update. Lets make it even more strange now. Deep sky objects it will not center, however if I pick a star any star and go to that star it is always in the center. Dead center every time.
I have tested the plate solve and it passed every time. I have plate solved and synced to the mount and it passed every time. Yet even with that and it saying the plate solve passed the object is not centered.
I have stared and compared my settings to others and we are the same as should be and have been for a long time.
What would make it center stars and not deep sky objects?
- admin
- Site Admin
- Posts: 17584
- Joined: Sat Feb 11, 2017 3:52 pm
- Location: Vale of the White Horse, UK
- Contact:
Re: GOTO's UPDATE WHAT?
Hi,
wow, this is possibly the strangest thing I have hear regarding SharpCap this year... Installing new versions, updating, uninstalling, reinstalling, any of that sort of thing will never touch your SharpCap settings - there is simply nothing in the install package that goes anywhere near the settings.
The things I can think of that would wipe your settings are
* Deliberately resetting them 'Reset Settings' button in the SharpCap settings window - I'm confident that you haven't tried that!
* Similarly using import settings would overwrite your settings, but again I assume you have been nowhere near that and I'm just including it for completeness.
* Switching to a different Windows user - all the settings are stored on a 'per user' basis, so a different user would start from scratch
* Downgrading to an old version of SharpCap (ie 4.1 back to 4.0). Changes made in 4.1 are stored in a separate area that 4.0 will not see. Upgrades are fine - when you first ran 4.1 it grabs all the settings that 4.0 uses and copies them across
* Something else that messes with the Windows registry could do this in theory, but it would be odd for something to just wipe the SharpCap settings out and not touch anything else
* In theory, something like Windows system restore (recovering to an older point in time) might do this
Lots of things there that in theory could cause the settings to be reset, but are all very unlikely
Not much help...
Another thing that comes to mind is if you have been using SharpCap 4.0, and have now switched to 4.1 - if you had ever used an older version of SharpCap 4.1 some time ago, that would have upgraded your SharpCap 4.0 settings *as they were at that point in time*, so switching to 4.1 now would not include any SharpCap 4.0 settings changes made recently...
Looking at the other problem of deep sky targets being off center but stars being centered, again a struggle to explain. It would be worth checking that the RA/Dec co-ordinates of some deep sky targets you are selecting match the published co-ordinates (should be J2000). But, but the star and DSO catalogs included in SharpCap have data in J2000 anyway. I suppose if you were picking objects from a custom catalog and that catalog had JNOW co-ordinates in it then you would see something like this.
I presume you are now on 4.1.14136, since that is the current auto-update version. Do you happen to know what version you were on before that?
cheers,
Robin
wow, this is possibly the strangest thing I have hear regarding SharpCap this year... Installing new versions, updating, uninstalling, reinstalling, any of that sort of thing will never touch your SharpCap settings - there is simply nothing in the install package that goes anywhere near the settings.
The things I can think of that would wipe your settings are
* Deliberately resetting them 'Reset Settings' button in the SharpCap settings window - I'm confident that you haven't tried that!
* Similarly using import settings would overwrite your settings, but again I assume you have been nowhere near that and I'm just including it for completeness.
* Switching to a different Windows user - all the settings are stored on a 'per user' basis, so a different user would start from scratch
* Downgrading to an old version of SharpCap (ie 4.1 back to 4.0). Changes made in 4.1 are stored in a separate area that 4.0 will not see. Upgrades are fine - when you first ran 4.1 it grabs all the settings that 4.0 uses and copies them across
* Something else that messes with the Windows registry could do this in theory, but it would be odd for something to just wipe the SharpCap settings out and not touch anything else
* In theory, something like Windows system restore (recovering to an older point in time) might do this
Lots of things there that in theory could cause the settings to be reset, but are all very unlikely
Another thing that comes to mind is if you have been using SharpCap 4.0, and have now switched to 4.1 - if you had ever used an older version of SharpCap 4.1 some time ago, that would have upgraded your SharpCap 4.0 settings *as they were at that point in time*, so switching to 4.1 now would not include any SharpCap 4.0 settings changes made recently...
Looking at the other problem of deep sky targets being off center but stars being centered, again a struggle to explain. It would be worth checking that the RA/Dec co-ordinates of some deep sky targets you are selecting match the published co-ordinates (should be J2000). But, but the star and DSO catalogs included in SharpCap have data in J2000 anyway. I suppose if you were picking objects from a custom catalog and that catalog had JNOW co-ordinates in it then you would see something like this.
I presume you are now on 4.1.14136, since that is the current auto-update version. Do you happen to know what version you were on before that?
cheers,
Robin
Re: GOTO's UPDATE WHAT?
Yes Robin I figured there wasn't a clue as to why it happened on that download install. I do not think SC had anything to do with it and your right
I touched nothing in the settings to cause the loss of data.
I have gone back before when I had a version I didn't like and ran older saved versions before this. Never ever have lost data even doing that. The updates and installs have always been clean and worked. This is a " It is what it is " thingy. I have seen worse.
I have after manty trials and attempts settled on version 4.1.14211 It is the one currently running.
The last version I was running before all this has been deleted, along with 3 other older version I had kept. All of them deleted now. The version Last weeks 3/10 update is the one I crashed on, I was using one from 4 or 5 weeks back before that . I should have left that one alone. LOL
As I said though. All of that has been squared away and seems fine.
This GOTO issue is my only real issue now.
One of the others watching and trying to help while broadcasting thought the data base could be wrong also. J2000 is suspect right now.
I'm still trying to figure it all out right now. I have rain and clouds forecasted for the next several days now. I will get back to this issue when I get clear skies to work with ASAP. Thank you for your input on this. I do appreciate it.
I touched nothing in the settings to cause the loss of data.
I have gone back before when I had a version I didn't like and ran older saved versions before this. Never ever have lost data even doing that. The updates and installs have always been clean and worked. This is a " It is what it is " thingy. I have seen worse.
I have after manty trials and attempts settled on version 4.1.14211 It is the one currently running.
The last version I was running before all this has been deleted, along with 3 other older version I had kept. All of them deleted now. The version Last weeks 3/10 update is the one I crashed on, I was using one from 4 or 5 weeks back before that . I should have left that one alone. LOL
As I said though. All of that has been squared away and seems fine.
This GOTO issue is my only real issue now.
One of the others watching and trying to help while broadcasting thought the data base could be wrong also. J2000 is suspect right now.
I'm still trying to figure it all out right now. I have rain and clouds forecasted for the next several days now. I will get back to this issue when I get clear skies to work with ASAP. Thank you for your input on this. I do appreciate it.
- admin
- Site Admin
- Posts: 17584
- Joined: Sat Feb 11, 2017 3:52 pm
- Location: Vale of the White Horse, UK
- Contact:
Re: GOTO's UPDATE WHAT?
Hi,
so, it is possible to get small errors in GOTO position from JNOW/J2000 confusion, but if you are just using the SharpCap built in catalogs then that would apply to everything or nothing. All the SharpCap built in data is J2000. Most mounts run JNOW and SharpCap will convert between the two as required. A few mounts run J2000 and SharpCap will detect that and skip the conversion.
At least in one case that I know of (EQMOD), it's possible to configure the mount to report that it does J2000, but in fact it doesn't. If you have that setup then SharpCap will believe the J2000 report it gets from EQMOD and skip the conversion and all GOTOs will be a bit off. That's actually an EQMOD bug that it shouldn't let you change that option without the EQMOD code taking over the job of converting epoch, but never mind...
So, that still doesn't help much with the DSO targets being the only things that are off. I think the best thing to do is to note the co-ordinates that SharpCap uses for a DSO target and a star target and check those against other sources. Stars should be spot on, some DSOs may be a little out for extended objects, but for a small target like a planetary nebula they should be very close. If you post the two targets chosen and the co-ordinates here, I can check that they are matching the ones in the SharpCap internal catalog. Please make sure to grab the co-ordinate values from the values shown in the 'Full Catalog' list of all targets window - those are the raw J2000 values from the catalog files.
cheers,
Robin
so, it is possible to get small errors in GOTO position from JNOW/J2000 confusion, but if you are just using the SharpCap built in catalogs then that would apply to everything or nothing. All the SharpCap built in data is J2000. Most mounts run JNOW and SharpCap will convert between the two as required. A few mounts run J2000 and SharpCap will detect that and skip the conversion.
At least in one case that I know of (EQMOD), it's possible to configure the mount to report that it does J2000, but in fact it doesn't. If you have that setup then SharpCap will believe the J2000 report it gets from EQMOD and skip the conversion and all GOTOs will be a bit off. That's actually an EQMOD bug that it shouldn't let you change that option without the EQMOD code taking over the job of converting epoch, but never mind...
So, that still doesn't help much with the DSO targets being the only things that are off. I think the best thing to do is to note the co-ordinates that SharpCap uses for a DSO target and a star target and check those against other sources. Stars should be spot on, some DSOs may be a little out for extended objects, but for a small target like a planetary nebula they should be very close. If you post the two targets chosen and the co-ordinates here, I can check that they are matching the ones in the SharpCap internal catalog. Please make sure to grab the co-ordinate values from the values shown in the 'Full Catalog' list of all targets window - those are the raw J2000 values from the catalog files.
cheers,
Robin
Re: GOTO's UPDATE WHAT?
I have clear skies tonight they say ,so I will try and do as you say and we will see. I'm also going to download the newest SC from this week.
Re: GOTO's UPDATE WHAT?
I have tried and used up every idea I can think of to resolve my issue. My one question now is how to remove SharpCap in its entirety. In the registries and all. I tried doing it but that did not work for me either. There were still items it found from before the removal and used again.
Re: GOTO's UPDATE WHAT?
I have tried and used up every idea I can think of to resolve my issue. My one question now is how to remove SharpCap in its entirety. In the registries and all. I tried doing it but that did not work for me either. There were still items it found from before the removal and used again when I installed it again.
- admin
- Site Admin
- Posts: 17584
- Joined: Sat Feb 11, 2017 3:52 pm
- Location: Vale of the White Horse, UK
- Contact:
Re: GOTO's UPDATE WHAT?
Hi,
you can reset every SharpCap setting to default from the main settings window - use the Reset button at the bottom left and tick all the boxes in the window that comes up. Before you do that, you can export your current settings to back them up - that way if the complete reset doesn't help, at least you can restore your current settings.
cheers,
Robin
you can reset every SharpCap setting to default from the main settings window - use the Reset button at the bottom left and tick all the boxes in the window that comes up. Before you do that, you can export your current settings to back them up - that way if the complete reset doesn't help, at least you can restore your current settings.
cheers,
Robin
Re: GOTO's UPDATE WHAT?
OK I can think of no more things to try on this. I have attached log files from last night. Not sure how much that helps. I tried many things many times as you will see in the logs.
Seems so strange the mount was dead center until this update was done. While the objects are still on the screen they are never in the center. They are all over the place with no consistent misses. It can miss top left,top right, bottom left, or bottom right. You never know
I know I have said all that before.
I have seen it go to the object and have it in the crosshair centered up, then recenter and sync and then move it away from center. The only way it ever centers an object is if I use the tool , click and recenter button once it is on my screen. I turned off the recenter sync and it still doesn't help.
When I have a star just off center of the cross hair I try and move the mount and center the star myself manually . I do that and it is fine and in the position dead center where I want it. The next frame comes up maybe 4 or 5 seconds and it has moved right back to the place it was before I manually moved it. Back where SharpCap placed it and thinks it should be.
In desperation, as a last resort and while it cost me nothing but time ( under warranty still ) I'm going to send my mount back in for a check and tune up, unless I hear something on this in the next day or so and there is a miracle cure or setting I have missed. Odds are very good on that one.
Wish I had an ASIAIR to try and use.
Seems so strange the mount was dead center until this update was done. While the objects are still on the screen they are never in the center. They are all over the place with no consistent misses. It can miss top left,top right, bottom left, or bottom right. You never know
I know I have said all that before.
I have seen it go to the object and have it in the crosshair centered up, then recenter and sync and then move it away from center. The only way it ever centers an object is if I use the tool , click and recenter button once it is on my screen. I turned off the recenter sync and it still doesn't help.
When I have a star just off center of the cross hair I try and move the mount and center the star myself manually . I do that and it is fine and in the position dead center where I want it. The next frame comes up maybe 4 or 5 seconds and it has moved right back to the place it was before I manually moved it. Back where SharpCap placed it and thinks it should be.
In desperation, as a last resort and while it cost me nothing but time ( under warranty still ) I'm going to send my mount back in for a check and tune up, unless I hear something on this in the next day or so and there is a miracle cure or setting I have missed. Odds are very good on that one.
Wish I had an ASIAIR to try and use.
- Attachments
-
- Log_2026-03-27T00_05_55-8812.log
- (905.48 KiB) Downloaded 4 times
- admin
- Site Admin
- Posts: 17584
- Joined: Sat Feb 11, 2017 3:52 pm
- Location: Vale of the White Horse, UK
- Contact:
Re: GOTO's UPDATE WHAT?
Hi,
thanks for posting the log - I can rule out a number of possible problems from the log, but there is no 'smoking gun' pointing to a problem.
From the log I can see
* The mount time seems to be correct - SharpCap checks it against the PC time and they agree to within 1s
* The mount is reporting correctly that it is a JNOW mount, and SharpCap is converting to/from J2000 co-ordinate values as required.
* The plate solving is working reasonably and is giving results that are believable - ranging from practically perfectly on target to about 1 degree out.
As far as I can see, all of the targets in this log were from SharpCap's built in catalog, and I checked the co-ordinates of a couple of them and they agreed with published online sources. I do see logs relating to other custom catalogs being loaded - if you see problems only with target from custom catalogs then it would be worth checking the catalog data is correct.
Which model of iOptron are you using? I have actually got a CEM70 on order, expecting it in a couple of weeks, so will be able to test out a similar setup when that arrives and is installed.
One possibility that comes to mind - go to the hardware settings page in SharpCap and increase the 'Mount settling time' a bit - you could get odd results if this is too low and the plate solving is happening before the mount has finally settled at the right position.
cheers,
Robin
thanks for posting the log - I can rule out a number of possible problems from the log, but there is no 'smoking gun' pointing to a problem.
From the log I can see
* The mount time seems to be correct - SharpCap checks it against the PC time and they agree to within 1s
* The mount is reporting correctly that it is a JNOW mount, and SharpCap is converting to/from J2000 co-ordinate values as required.
* The plate solving is working reasonably and is giving results that are believable - ranging from practically perfectly on target to about 1 degree out.
As far as I can see, all of the targets in this log were from SharpCap's built in catalog, and I checked the co-ordinates of a couple of them and they agreed with published online sources. I do see logs relating to other custom catalogs being loaded - if you see problems only with target from custom catalogs then it would be worth checking the catalog data is correct.
Which model of iOptron are you using? I have actually got a CEM70 on order, expecting it in a couple of weeks, so will be able to test out a similar setup when that arrives and is installed.
One possibility that comes to mind - go to the hardware settings page in SharpCap and increase the 'Mount settling time' a bit - you could get odd results if this is too low and the plate solving is happening before the mount has finally settled at the right position.
cheers,
Robin