Patterning effects in SER files of the moon?

Anything that doesn't fit into any of the other forums
timh
Posts: 690
Joined: Mon Aug 26, 2019 5:50 pm

Patterning effects in SER files of the moon?

#1

Post by timh »

Does anyone have an explanation for why my lunar images (below) were dominated by stripy patterning effects when I tried using an ASI 294 MM mono camera to capture SER files of the moon?

In 46 Mb 'unlocked' mode the pixel size of the camera is 2.3 um. The telescope was an OO (UK) VX12 F4 300 mm Newtonian with a 2X Barlow. Thus with this set up the image scale was 0.25 arcsec/ pixel.

A 3500 frame .SER file was captured as below in SC4.1 at 23 fps – the histogram looked about right at 11 ms and gain 121.

The best quality 30% of frames were stacked in AS 3! and processed in Registax and/ or PixInsight. However all attempts at sharpening just seemed to enhance a stripy background grid pattern …. It became evident that however I tried processing the file (e.g. via PIPP and conversion to AVI) exactly the same patterning effect was observed. This was true also when processing the ser file via the SC4.1 live stacking tool and using the sharpening tools therein.

I am wondering whether this might be a problem with the ASI294 MM camera because there was no such effect using an ASI 715MC OSC (1.45 um pixel) camera and capturing RAW8 files. Or did I make some error in capture settings (below)?

Images show images of the central peak in Theophilus --- mono8 with the ASI294 MM camera and one (not brilliantly focused) with the ASI 715MC.

Any help or suggestions appreciated

---------------------------------------------------------

[ZWO ASI294MM Pro]
CameraSerialNumber=1D06570E17000900
FrameType=Light
Pan=3492
Tilt=2304
Output Format=SER file (*.ser)
Binning=1
Resolution=1280x1024
Read Mode=46 Megapixel
Colour Space=MONO8
Exposure/Gain Shift=0
High Speed Mode=On
Turbo USB=80(Auto)
Flip=None
Frame Rate Limit=Maximum
Gain=121
Exposure=10.9450ms
Timestamp Frames=Off
Brightness=10
Cooler Power=0
Temperature=15.1
Target Temperature=-5
Cooler=Off
Auto Exp Max Gain=350
Auto Exp Max Exp MS=30000
Auto Exp Target Brightness=100
CA Reduction/Synthetic Blue=Off
Mask over exposed pixels=Off
Flip (after dark/flat)=None
Trail Width=3
Minimum Trail Length=100
Trail Detection Sensitivity=9
Remove Satellite Trails=Off
Background Subtraction=Off
Planet/Disk Stabilization=Off
Banding Threshold=10
Banding Suppression=0
Apply Flat=None
Dark Scaling (Experimental)=Off
Hot Pixel Sensitivity=5
Subtract Dark=None
DisplayStretchEnable=1
NegativeDisplay=0
Display Black Point=0
Display MidTone Point=0.5245353968549946
Display White Point=1
Notes=
Pegasus Astro Focus Controller=72370
Focuser Temperature=9.75
iOptron CEM120,70,40,26, GEM, HEM, HAE, HAZ series and SkyHunter Mount=RA=08:33:32.5,Dec=+22:25:20 (JNOW)
TimeStamp=2025-05-03T21:07:56.1709157Z
SharpCapVersion=4.1.12946.0
StartCapture=2025-05-03T21:07:56.1604761Z
MidCapture=2025-05-03T21:09:11.2845462Z
EndCapture=2025-05-03T21:10:26.4086163Z
JDStartCapture=2460799.380511
JDMidCapture=2460799.381381
JDEndCapture=2460799.382250
Duration=150.248s
FrameCount=3534
ActualFrameRate=23.5211fps
TimeZone=+1.00
Attachments
Theophiluscompare.jpg
Theophiluscompare.jpg (406.79 KiB) Viewed 2423 times
User avatar
turfpit
Posts: 2280
Joined: Mon Feb 13, 2017 8:13 pm
Location: UK
Contact:

Re: Patterning effects in SER files of the moon?

#2

Post by turfpit »

Tim

Try the 4.63µm pixel size and see what happens.

Also see:

AS_column_noise_correction.JPG
AS_column_noise_correction.JPG (49.49 KiB) Viewed 2414 times

Also see https://www.cloudynights.com/gallery/im ... cal-lines/

Dave
timh
Posts: 690
Joined: Mon Aug 26, 2019 5:50 pm

Re: Patterning effects in SER files of the moon?

#3

Post by timh »

Thanks (yet again) Dave

The AS3! settings didn't make a difference. 4.63 um pixels may well do but then the image scale is getting a bit big

I have discovered though that I am not the only sufferer with this problem

https://www.cloudynights.com/topic/9546 ... -troubles/

If you follow the thread right down to the second cloudy nights thread linked to the first thread it seems that it might actually be a Sharpcap problem in the way it interacts with this particular camera -- It looks like Borodog reported it back to Robin also?

Tim
User avatar
admin
Site Admin
Posts: 17584
Joined: Sat Feb 11, 2017 3:52 pm
Location: Vale of the White Horse, UK
Contact:

Re: Patterning effects in SER files of the moon?

#4

Post by admin »

Hi,

this is *probably* related to the ROI settings of the camera in conjunction with the 46 megapixel mode on the 294MM. Certain ROI settings seem to result in the camera arranging the pixels in the wrong order in the resulting image.

The same issue came up on CloudyNights (https://www.cloudynights.com/topic/9546 ... ry13983642) a couple of months ago, and after some discussion the ROI settings came up as the most likely cause. I then asked if anyone could do some tests to confirm that as the cause of the problem and no-one ever came back to me :(

My suspicion is that the Pan and Tilt values for this camera in 46Mp mode need to be multiples of either 8 or 16 to give 'good' images in ROI mode - normally for ZWO cameras they just have to be even numbers. In your case above, the Pan value in use (the horizontal offset of the ROI) is divisible by 4 but not 8 or 16.

If you have a chance to run some tests (on a terrestrial target might be enough to see the mis-ordered pixels live - particularly if you use SharpCap's solar system live stacking to sharpen?), please let me know the results so I can set the code up to apply the right rules.

cheers,

Robin
timh
Posts: 690
Joined: Mon Aug 26, 2019 5:50 pm

Re: Patterning effects in SER files of the moon?

#5

Post by timh »

Thanks Robin,

I can confirm that all 4 ser files - a range of ROIs - showed the same patterning and, consistent with your hypothesis, in all cases either the PAN or TILT number was not a multiple of 8 or 16. I will let you know what happens as soon as I test again using PAN and TILT values that do conform to your rule.

Tim
timh
Posts: 690
Joined: Mon Aug 26, 2019 5:50 pm

Re: Patterning effects in SER files of the moon?

#6

Post by timh »

Hi Robin,

I did a quick test and did not observe any effect of the PAN and TILT values being multiples of 8 or not. The patterning still looked similar
Attachments
Garage_test.jpg
Garage_test.jpg (138.4 KiB) Viewed 2381 times
User avatar
admin
Site Admin
Posts: 17584
Joined: Sat Feb 11, 2017 3:52 pm
Location: Vale of the White Horse, UK
Contact:

Re: Patterning effects in SER files of the moon?

#7

Post by admin »

Hi Tim,

thanks for trying - scratch one idea then :(

Any chance you can test with Pan and Tilt set both to zero? See if that gives an OK image? It might be good to also set the width/height to a power of 2 (ie 1024x1024). I guess the question I am really asking is "can we find any Pan/Tilt/ROI Area settings which give a good picture?" If we can find one set of settings that work, then start finding others, we can spot the pattern hopefully.

cheers,

Robin
timh
Posts: 690
Joined: Mon Aug 26, 2019 5:50 pm

Re: Patterning effects in SER files of the moon?

#8

Post by timh »

Yes of course. Any ideas that occur feel free to ask since I can test them out easily enough.

I set pan and tilt to zero and tried ROIs of 1280 x 1024 and 1024 x 768 at 46 Mb but still the same. The pattern is obvious just in the blown up live view --- and not there as soon as I switch to 11Mb. The menu options to not allow me to set both width and height of the ROI to a power of 2 unfortunately

In the meantime further control experiments (involving further minute examination of my neighbours property) at 46Mb (2.3 um pixel) resolution show

1) same grid effect at MONO 16 setting as at MONO 8
2) same effect at a range of ROI sizes (even when everything - pan - tilt and the pixel dimensions of ROI were all multiples of 8)

control experiments also confirmed that there was no such effect at either mono8 or mono16 at 4.63 um pixel setting and 11 Mb

Tim
Last edited by timh on Tue May 06, 2025 7:01 pm, edited 2 times in total.
User avatar
turfpit
Posts: 2280
Joined: Mon Feb 13, 2017 8:13 pm
Location: UK
Contact:

Re: Patterning effects in SER files of the moon?

#9

Post by turfpit »

Tim

From the Astronomy Tools CCD Suitability Calculator:

ASI294_bin1mode.JPG
ASI294_bin1mode.JPG (68.62 KiB) Viewed 2300 times

ASI294_bin2mode.JPG
ASI294_bin2mode.JPG (65.56 KiB) Viewed 2300 times

I have used an Atik 314E (4.65µm), Atik 314L+ (6.45µm) and Skyris 618M (5.6µm) on lunar images.

Dave
timh
Posts: 690
Joined: Mon Aug 26, 2019 5:50 pm

Re: Patterning effects in SER files of the moon?

#10

Post by timh »

Hi Dave,
I agree generally with that calculator for most deepsky work but not for everything. So for semi-lucky imaging (5-10s subs) and using deconvolution to improve resolution beyond the average seeing oversampling is a condition of it working (i.e. much more detail is recoverable from data sampled at 0.4 rather than 0.8 arcsec/ pixel -- and there is barely any effect of deconvolution at all when data is sampled at 1.5 arcsec/ pixel - for example)

Similarly and more so for lunar surely? With such very short subs the potential of lucky imaging can be fully realised and - at least up to a certain aperture - it is reasonable to expect to start to approach the Dawes limit - so for a 12 inch aperture then - in theory - points 0.5 arcsec apart could be resolvable. But in order to realise that potential resolution the pixel image scale has to be small enough to at least 2-3X sample that separation (Nyquist-Shannon sampling theorem). That is why I thought it important to include the 2X Barlow and get the image scale down to 0.25 or 0.125 arcsec / pixel. So - for example - my expectation would be that the 0.7 mile craterlet in Plato would never have been detectable had I been running with 4.63 um pixels. I may have the wrong end of the stick here but I think that this logic is correct?

Tim
Post Reply