Choice SSDs

Anything that doesn't fit into any of the other forums
Altocumulus
Posts: 180
Joined: Sun Jan 27, 2019 9:48 am

Choice SSDs

#1

Post by Altocumulus »

Hi all,

Can anyone recommend any tried and trusted SSDs.

I've started noticing significant buffering issues with onboard SSDs in 3 different PCs, and 2 external Scandisk 1TB SSDs. By significant I mean buffering issues on save with cameras, even as low as 17fps and 2000 frames.

On a recent mosaic Sharpcap started hanging whilst it caught up with a buffering backlog, but even non-mosaics are problematic.

External drives are emptied onto a NAS after each daily session. Bar space for programs, there's room available on the PCs.
Jean-Francois
Posts: 858
Joined: Sun Oct 13, 2019 10:52 am
Location: Germany

Re: Choice SSDs

#2

Post by Jean-Francois »

Hello,

I have 1 Samsung T5 and 2 Samsung T7 SSD (with 512 GB, 1 TB and 2 TB capacities) for many years.
All are working fine with all my computers.

Important is the USB3 connection.
Note that USB3 is not all the time the maximum possible transfer rate.
You have (too much) variations. I prefer to use the USB C connector on the computer if available.
But it is better to have a look at the USB characteristics of the computer.
Some computers have a USB hub on some USB3 connectors and a direct connection to the processor with other connectors.
If you use a desktop computer ... the "front" USB are more of the time through a hub, the "back" USB are sometime direct connected to the board.

If you have not the SharpCap Pro version, think about to upgrade to the Pro, which can set more RAM memory for images buffering.

Regards,
Jean-Francois
Altocumulus
Posts: 180
Joined: Sun Jan 27, 2019 9:48 am

Re: Choice SSDs

#3

Post by Altocumulus »

Thank you, I have the pro licence.

USB3 is used throughout, I don't have C connections - sadly!

I think, though, I'm looking at this incorrectly. Sharpcap speed test suggested write speeds of 300mbs, but that falls dramatically slow when actual imaging takes place, even 1000 frame SER at 17fps there's buffering. At 126fps Sharpcap hangs at times whilst trying to catchup with over 2000 frames stuck in buffer ( when imaging for mosaics, even 4 panel - at 34 it gets hairy! ).

Happens no matter the camera or cable. It's not Sharpcap as it's not flagged by anyone else.

Everything was mostly fine last year, so what changes have I made?

Previously I had PC on mount, controlled by another PC/laptop with one or two screens. I occasionally saw lagging in control. I also was conscious an extra PC in the mix ( multiply by two as I run two mounts ) means more electricity.

I've now only the mount PC in place, wireless mouse. Two monitors attached directly.

I can't check, today, as it's cloudy, but we are promised sunshine next few days.

I think the culprit is the two screens directly attached to the PC mount, At least I hope that's the culprit? Go back to as was is a simple step to take.
Altocumulus
Posts: 180
Joined: Sun Jan 27, 2019 9:48 am

Re: Choice SSDs

#5

Post by Altocumulus »

Thanks Dave,

Seagate are the 2 external ones I have. I thought windows, through optimisation, automatically sorted out issues on maintaining the drives, I have them set as automatic, but will check if trim is mentioned.

All mount pcs are win 11. 2 laptops are 10, but they only control.
User avatar
turfpit
Posts: 2280
Joined: Mon Feb 13, 2017 8:13 pm
Location: UK
Contact:

Re: Choice SSDs

#6

Post by turfpit »

My 2015 capture laptop has a SATA2 drive by design, it performs well capturing large amounts of lunar data at 120fps from a USB3 camera. No evidence of buffering, slowdowns or dropped frames.

The links (to articles from reputable drive manufacturers) should give you some things to check.

Dave
User avatar
admin
Site Admin
Posts: 17584
Joined: Sat Feb 11, 2017 3:52 pm
Location: Vale of the White Horse, UK
Contact:

Re: Choice SSDs

#7

Post by admin »

Hi,

modern SSDs tend to get their large capacity by putting multiple (2, 3 or even 4) bits into a single flash cell. Sadly writing to this multi level flash is relatively slow, which negates the point of SSDs to some extent. So, to mitigate this, manufacturers make part of the SSD get used as single bit per cell (SLC) flash for quickly writing data. Then, the SSD migrates the new data to the slower multi level flash in the background.

That works great if you don't write big chunks of data at one go, but if you are writing a significant fraction of the size of the SSD in one short session, you can fill up the fast write area and start getting slow data transfer rates from having to directly write to the slower multi level area. This has been observed on multiple types/brands of SSD.

The 'fast' area is often a percentage of the size of the SSD (maybe 10%, maybe more or less on some models/brands). It's worth reading SSD performance reviews in some details to see if they do a 'bulk write' test to check out this sort of behaviour and how different models perform.

cheers,

Robin
Altocumulus
Posts: 180
Joined: Sun Jan 27, 2019 9:48 am

Re: Choice SSDs

#8

Post by Altocumulus »

Cheers, Robin.

Though what's worrying is I seem to have suddenly developed slowness across all pcs and external drives, and all are SSD.

It must be something else that's happening?
User avatar
turfpit
Posts: 2280
Joined: Mon Feb 13, 2017 8:13 pm
Location: UK
Contact:

Re: Choice SSDs

#9

Post by turfpit »

Useful information there Robin.

After an imaging session, I copy the data from the capture laptop to an external USB drive attached to my workstation. These files are then copied to an internal SSD for processing.

My Atik 314L files are 2.8Mb, 183M/C files are 38Mb. With some of the modern sensors, the file sizes are huge.

A subtle change to a big sensor camera can mean a significant increase in the amount of data being moved around a system.

Hence a formerly performant system can suddenly, for no apparent reason, have performance issues.

Change is the enemy of progress.

Dave
Altocumulus
Posts: 180
Joined: Sun Jan 27, 2019 9:48 am

Re: Choice SSDs

#10

Post by Altocumulus »

I do the same, Dave.

Except my transfer selects as a cut and sent to a NAS - usually after a run through PIPP.

My 178 generates nothing like the the Apollo Max, but even the 178 is now buffering at 17fps - even for 1000 frames.
Post Reply