Page 1 of 1

Effect of OIII & Ha filter on histograms

Posted: Mon Oct 20, 2025 9:19 pm
by jpiquette
I thought I would like to capture some flat frames with my OIII & Ha filter in place, assuming that that is what would be needed for processing frames captured with that filter. After entering the flats capture process, I was surprised to see that the histogram looked rather strange. The red plot was very narrow and thin, and entirely at the left end of the plot. The green plot looked fairly normal, but I could not even see the blue plot. However, the combined white plot still looked pretty normal, lying between about 30% and 60% on the graph.

Is this behavior normal for the histogram with that filter in place? Also, I am confused about where the controls are located for adjusting the histogram shapes.

Also, am I mistaken that flats should be taken with the filter in place if I am going to be capturing light frames with the filter?

Jean

Re: Effect of OIII & Ha filter on histograms

Posted: Tue Oct 21, 2025 12:36 pm
by admin
Hi Jean,

yes, this is pretty much expected - the OIII filter passes only green light, so you will see normal brightness in the green channel and not much in either red or blue (the small amount you do see is the result of the filters for the red/blue pixels in the camera passing *some* light in the green area of the spectrum that the OIII filter lets through - just not much). Using the H-alpha filter which only passes red, you would see a normal red histogram and practically nothing in blue or green.

Not many people would see this effect, since it's a bit unusual to do narrowband imaging with a colour camera - if you are using your h-alpha filter for instance then 3/4 of the pixels of your camera will be basically doing nothing, since they (the green and blue ones) are only sensitive to wavelengths that the h-alpha filter is blocking. This is the reason that most people use a mono camera for narrowband (or use a tri-quad band filter with a colour camera).

All that being said, you do want to take flats with the filter in place, as that way they can correct for any dust shadows or vignetting caused by the filter. You should expose the flats for the channel that is brightest with that filter and not worry about the others being very low.

cheers,

Robin