Page 1 of 1

Plate solving question

Posted: Tue Jan 03, 2023 2:45 pm
by Moonstruck
Hello,
I have been using my guide camera (ZWO asi 174MM) and guide scope (Skywatcher Evoguide 50) to plate solve. It works great about 50% of the time. I would like to get it to work much more often. When it doesn't work I get a variety of messages, some indicating it has reached the maxim magnitude of the star database, and other messages (which I don't recall now). Maybe my Sharpcap settings are not correct. What are the recommended gain, exposure, and other settings I should use for this camera and scope to get it to work properly more often? Or are my issues possibly related to focus, alignment, etc? Not sure where to start here. I wish I had recorded what settings I used when it worked successfully, but unfortunately I didn't. Can you give me some general guidance on the proper settings I should use?

Re: Plate solving question

Posted: Wed Jan 04, 2023 4:29 pm
by admin
Hi,

the basic guidance would be make sure that there area plenty of stars visible for the plate solving to work on and that they are nice and sharply focused. Do make sure that the display stretch is turned off when judging the number of stars visible, as it is easy to forget that is turned on and think the image looks great, whereas in fact it is really dim and only visible due to the stretch.

Good starting points for settings would be 4s exposure, gain at half way point or higher. Similar settings to those you would use for polar alignment (for the same reason - seeing plenty of stars).

If you still have issues, save a few images to PNG or FITS that fail and share them here for further investigation.

thanks,

Robin

Re: Plate solving question

Posted: Wed Jan 04, 2023 7:02 pm
by Moonstruck
Thanks very much Robin. This helps! I was probably using anywhere from 0.5 to 1 sec exposure time most of the time- maybe that wasn't long enough for a good capture- I'll use around 4 sec from now on, as you suggested. I won't be imaging for a while to test this- it's too cold here in CT (USA) but I'll be back in touch if I have any issues when I start back up again in the spring.

Cheers,
John

Re: Plate solving question

Posted: Tue Mar 21, 2023 7:27 pm
by Moonstruck
Hi Robin,
I tried using plate solving last night (ASTAP) but it was giving me issues again - it plate solved successfully only around 20% of the time. Other times I got error messages indicating it had reached the maximum magnitude of the star database, or that I should try lowering the gain or exposure. I am not sure what it means to have reached the maximum magnitude of the star database. And lowering the gain and exposure didn't work - I tried many different combinations of exposure time and gain. It just did not want to plate solve!!

Initially I took your previous suggestion and set the gain to over 50% and the exposure to 4 sec, but that didn't work most of the time. Note - the stars were very well-focused and there were a lot of them (bright and crisp) so I don't think poor focus was the issue. And my sharpcap polar alignment was "excellent," so alignment doesn't appear to be the issue either... any idea what is going on here? Should I try another plate solving program? If so, which one? I really need to get this working... without plate solving capability it will be very difficult to find any dim targets at all.

Another issue I had was that one time it successfully plate -solved and automatically slewed my mount, but the target was not in the field of view when it stopped. Any idea what may have caused that? It was a big, relatively bright target (the whirlpool galaxy) so I should have seen it if it were there.

Last, I have a general question. I use a C8 Edge for imaging but use my piggy-backed Skywatcher 50 ED guide scope for alignment and plate solving. I (hopefully) find the target using plate-solving with the guide scope, then switch to the C8 in sharpcap for imaging. Is it Ok to keep switching back and forth between imaging and guide cameras like that, or does that "confuse" the program? Does it adversely affect anything when I switch back and forth? I am wondering if I should be doing that. Could that be affecting my plate solving capabilities?

Re: Plate solving question

Posted: Tue Mar 21, 2023 7:42 pm
by admin
Hi,

switching back and forth between the two different scopes may be part of the problem. Unless you are very lucky (and have a very large sensor imaging camera), the fields of view of the two systems will be quite different. For this to work at all, you will need to leave the focal length setting in SharpCap set to 'do not use', which will then mean that SharpCap will ask Astap to check a range of possible fields of view. In theory that should work, but the system is optimised for using the same field of view over and over again. If you plate solve succesfully at (say) a 1 degree FOV, Astap will remember that for the next try. It will only try other field sizes in a second pass after the 1 degree remembered value fails.

As for the error 'Reached Maximum Magnitude', that means that Astap has run out of fainter stars to try - basically at large fields of view it can use relatively bright stars for solving, but as you make the field smaller, it has to use fainter and fainter stars to get enough in each possible view area. Eventually it cannot go any smaller as it has run out of stars in the star database.

If it is advising you to reduce gain/exposure then it's possible that too many stars are being detected, which can confuse the system, particularly if they are small and pointlike. Try adjusting the focus off a bit to make the stars a bit bigger and see if that helps (it stops the stars from being largely saturated, so Astap can do a better job of estimating which are the brightest).

If all else fails, you could try Ansvr/Astrotortilla/ASPS as alternatives, or post some captured image files here that fail to solve for further investigation.

cheers,

Robin

Re: Plate solving question

Posted: Tue Mar 21, 2023 9:48 pm
by Moonstruck
Thanks. The reason I was switching back and forth was because I read somewhere that small scopes with a larger FOV are better suited for plate solving. Thus the use of my guide scope. But can I use my C8 Edge scope with an 0.7 reducer and asi 294 camera for plate solving? That way I wouldn't have to switch back and forth. And can the C8 and reducer also be used for polar alignment? Or is the FOV too small?

Also, I have two imaging scopes - the C8 I mentioned and a skywatcher Esprit 100ED refractor. Can I alternate between using these scopes on different days without creating a plate solving incompatibility problem? In other words, if I use the C8, shut the system down, turn everything off, and start it back up using the refractor, will astap remember the C8's FOV from last time, or doesn't it matter?

Re: Plate solving question

Posted: Wed Mar 22, 2023 1:37 pm
by admin
Hi,

with the reducer and the 294, you will get a FOV of about 0.7x0.5 degrees, which is obviously a bit larger than without the reducer, so should have a better chance of plate solving. You can use the astronomy tools website to check out this sort of thing : https://astronomy.tools/calculators/field_of_view/

As long as you don't try to set the focal length in the SharpCap settings (or you do set it and update it every time you change telescope) then Astap should work, although it will likely be slow the first run after changing focal length. If you have been using the EdgeHD+Reducer+294, it will remember the 0.5 degree field height and try that scale first. If you have changed to the Esprit100 then it will fail at the first try with 0.5 degree field height, but SharpCap will automatically retry asking Astap to try a range of field heights, which should then succeed.

cheers,

Robin

Re: Plate solving question

Posted: Wed Mar 22, 2023 3:44 pm
by Moonstruck
Thanks Robin. Based on your response, here is my plan. I will leave the focal length setting on "from ASCOM Mount" and try plate solving with my C8, asi 294 and 0.7 reducer. Hopefully that will work. Then if I switch to my Esprit 100 I will leave the focal length setting on "from ASCOM Mount" and hopefully plate solving will work the second time it tries.

If by chance the above does not work with my C8, I will try entering "do not use" for a focal length setting, and try using my piggy-backed guide scope (ED50 with asi 174mm camera) for plate solving again, and switch back to my C8 for imaging. I really hope I don't have to do that again since it is kind of a pain switching back and forth! But if I do hopefully the "do not use" focal length setting will help.

For polar alignment with the C8 I will try it with the reducer and asi 294 and see if that works.

Thanks again. If any of my plan above won't work please advise. It will be cloudy here in New England for the next week or so but I am anxious to get out and try it when it clears!

John

Re: Plate solving question

Posted: Thu Mar 23, 2023 2:13 pm
by admin
Hi John,

I don't think the first approach will work - if SharpCap knows the focal length of the telescope (or thinks it does) and the pixel size of the camera (which it will know) then it does not do the 'second try' all scales attempt at plate solving. The second approach should be fine.

cheers,

Robin