A guiding question...
Posted: Sat Sep 24, 2022 4:16 pm
Hi folks,
currently I am reworking the code that deals with dithering (and monitoring guiding) while live stacking, and I've come across a question that it would be interesting to get some additional viewpoints on...
The question is
If you have set the application up to stop stacking if guiding is lost, what does that really mean?
* Should any loss of guiding during a frame count as 'guiding lost'? Even if it is just 1-2s during a relatively long frame like 120s?
* Should there be a limit - ie guiding lost for more than 5% of frame length means lost, otherwise ignore?
For reference, the way it currently works in live stacking is that if guiding is active at the end of a frame then the frame is considered good, which isn't right whichever way you look at it. For capture with the sequencer, it works a different way - if the frame is more than 95% complete when guiding is lost then it is kept, otherwise it is cancelled.
Anyway, if there is a 'right' answer then it is probably to throw away the frame if guiding is lost at all, but it's not necessarily the best practical answer.
Any opinions?
cheers,
Robin
currently I am reworking the code that deals with dithering (and monitoring guiding) while live stacking, and I've come across a question that it would be interesting to get some additional viewpoints on...
The question is
If you have set the application up to stop stacking if guiding is lost, what does that really mean?
* Should any loss of guiding during a frame count as 'guiding lost'? Even if it is just 1-2s during a relatively long frame like 120s?
* Should there be a limit - ie guiding lost for more than 5% of frame length means lost, otherwise ignore?
For reference, the way it currently works in live stacking is that if guiding is active at the end of a frame then the frame is considered good, which isn't right whichever way you look at it. For capture with the sequencer, it works a different way - if the frame is more than 95% complete when guiding is lost then it is kept, otherwise it is cancelled.
Anyway, if there is a 'right' answer then it is probably to throw away the frame if guiding is lost at all, but it's not necessarily the best practical answer.
Any opinions?
cheers,
Robin