Robin,
Oops sorry about that. I didn’t even think about that. It’s overcast for a while here in Arizona. I’ll get you the correct file when it clears.
SharpCap latest version ...
Re: SharpCap latest version ...
Robin,
sorry it took so long to get ack to this. I was doing EAA and the fwhm filter was almost to the top. I took a pic of the filter read out then when finished with stack I turned on focus and took a pic of that screen. The values are very different. I included several individual raw frames and the nights log file. Its really strange without changing anything and starting another livestack run within a degree of first the fwhm totally changes. Here is the link.
https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fo/dr2atv1a ... tuhef&dl=0
sorry it took so long to get ack to this. I was doing EAA and the fwhm filter was almost to the top. I took a pic of the filter read out then when finished with stack I turned on focus and took a pic of that screen. The values are very different. I included several individual raw frames and the nights log file. Its really strange without changing anything and starting another livestack run within a degree of first the fwhm totally changes. Here is the link.
https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fo/dr2atv1a ... tuhef&dl=0
- admin
- Site Admin
- Posts: 17580
- Joined: Sat Feb 11, 2017 3:52 pm
- Location: Vale of the White Horse, UK
- Contact:
Re: SharpCap latest version ...
Hi George,
thanks for sharing those file - I have tested with those and I can get an FWHM values of between about 5 and 6.2 out of them - depending on the various settings for star detection (those are separate in live stacking from focus, so you can get different values for the two functions due to different settings). PixInsight comes up with between about 5.2 and 5.5 (again depending on settings), so that all seems reasonable.
That doesn't help explain the low values of ~3 or the high value of ~10 that you were seeing. I can see in one of your screenshots that the number of stars was low (12 I think) - that can lead to more variable values. In particular, you could get higher than expected values if some of the small galaxies in view are being detected and measured as stars.
This does just highlight that FWHM values should really only be used to distinguish between good/bad frames due to changes in focus/conditions. Changing the star detection settings or moving to another field of view will also change the result. The latter should be relatively minor if you are detecting lots of stars (50+), but can be significant for small numbers of stars.
cheers,
Robin
thanks for sharing those file - I have tested with those and I can get an FWHM values of between about 5 and 6.2 out of them - depending on the various settings for star detection (those are separate in live stacking from focus, so you can get different values for the two functions due to different settings). PixInsight comes up with between about 5.2 and 5.5 (again depending on settings), so that all seems reasonable.
That doesn't help explain the low values of ~3 or the high value of ~10 that you were seeing. I can see in one of your screenshots that the number of stars was low (12 I think) - that can lead to more variable values. In particular, you could get higher than expected values if some of the small galaxies in view are being detected and measured as stars.
This does just highlight that FWHM values should really only be used to distinguish between good/bad frames due to changes in focus/conditions. Changing the star detection settings or moving to another field of view will also change the result. The latter should be relatively minor if you are detecting lots of stars (50+), but can be significant for small numbers of stars.
cheers,
Robin
Re: SharpCap latest version ...
Robin,
I have a bad tendency of setting up eaa run and leaving the fwhm filter at the previous run setting. Most of the time works great. Once in awhile I leave the scope and come back to find the fwhm values much higher, rejecting a lot of frames. I really need to make sure the filter is set right when starting run. You’ve made this astrophotography thing to easy
. Thanks for all your help. Sc is awesome!!
I have a bad tendency of setting up eaa run and leaving the fwhm filter at the previous run setting. Most of the time works great. Once in awhile I leave the scope and come back to find the fwhm values much higher, rejecting a lot of frames. I really need to make sure the filter is set right when starting run. You’ve made this astrophotography thing to easy
Re: SharpCap latest version ...
Robin,
I changed to 200 gain from 100 gain on my 533 and I didn’t get the variance in the fwhm all night. Thought you might want to know.
I changed to 200 gain from 100 gain on my 533 and I didn’t get the variance in the fwhm all night. Thought you might want to know.