Re: Flats are overcompensating for vignetting
Posted: Sun Apr 02, 2023 3:03 pm
Craig
Don't worry about fat or thin histograms - these can vary depending on the camera or FITS software.
As Brian suggests, the flats are ok for a large sensor. Are you applying only flats to your light frames? If that is the case then you need to also capture some darks and apply darks + flats to your light frames.
Given your modern camera you probably need to be applying darks, flats and dark flats. I notice in your ASTAP image that you are using Sharpcap 3.2. An upgrade to SC 4.0 will allow you to capture dark flats along with the flats.
Below is a Sharpcap 4.0 flat capture with an Altair 183C (sensor 5440x3648). Note the option to capture and subtract dark flat frames. Also the master flat displayed in FITS Liberator - note the mean ADU of 29,000.
Dave
This was the Master Flat generated
Don't worry about fat or thin histograms - these can vary depending on the camera or FITS software.
As Brian suggests, the flats are ok for a large sensor. Are you applying only flats to your light frames? If that is the case then you need to also capture some darks and apply darks + flats to your light frames.
Given your modern camera you probably need to be applying darks, flats and dark flats. I notice in your ASTAP image that you are using Sharpcap 3.2. An upgrade to SC 4.0 will allow you to capture dark flats along with the flats.
Below is a Sharpcap 4.0 flat capture with an Altair 183C (sensor 5440x3648). Note the option to capture and subtract dark flat frames. Also the master flat displayed in FITS Liberator - note the mean ADU of 29,000.
Dave
This was the Master Flat generated