32-bit stack in Siril

Anything that doesn't fit into any of the other forums
Post Reply
donstim
Posts: 132
Joined: Wed Sep 19, 2018 5:35 am

32-bit stack in Siril

#1

Post by donstim »

In trying to open a FITS file in Siril (version 1.4.0-beta 2) that was saved in SharpCap as a Raw (32 Bit) Stack in Live Stacking, I am presented with a totally black screen (or totally white if "autostretch" is selected). If I then try to stretch the linear image, I get a warning that the image contains pixel values outside of the range of 0 to 1 (with a minimum of 6.875 and a maximum of 17385.297). It gives me the options of clipping or rescaling the pixel values. After rescaling, the image appears as expected.

Do I have something mis-set in SharpCap, or is Siril not reading/interpreting the FITS header correctly or something?
Gfischer
Posts: 323
Joined: Thu Jun 22, 2023 4:20 pm

Re: 32-bit stack in Siril

#2

Post by Gfischer »

Hi I use Siril for 32bit livestack raw stacks and had same issue. Just make sure the box in settings under saving tab. Under file format options group save 32 bit fits is unchecked.
donstim
Posts: 132
Joined: Wed Sep 19, 2018 5:35 am

Re: 32-bit stack in Siril

#3

Post by donstim »

I guess you mean the save 32-bit as floating point is unchecked? Okay, I had that checked so that it would be compatible with GIMP. I guess I need to determine whether I will first open the file in GIMP or in Siril. If I rescale the pixel levels in Siril and save that as a fits file, I can still open it in GIMP. But if I open the original file in GIMP and export it as a new fits file, SIril cannot open it at all.

So, it seems the best option for me at present is to still save the 32-bt stack as floating point in SharpCap, then when opening it in Siril, try to do a stretch so that the option to rescale it comes up. Rescale it and go on from there.
Gfischer
Posts: 323
Joined: Thu Jun 22, 2023 4:20 pm

Re: 32-bit stack in Siril

#4

Post by Gfischer »

I use Siril to crop, color calibration, background subtraction stretch and color saturation. Then save as a 32bit tif. Then open in astrosurface sharpen-noise reduction. Then I add an edge identifier type line. All free software. Got to love it😀
donstim
Posts: 132
Joined: Wed Sep 19, 2018 5:35 am

Re: 32-bit stack in Siril

#5

Post by donstim »

For sure!! I use Siril in much the same way, but in addition use the integrated GraXpert background extraction and noise reduction, and also use StarNet and star synthesis to fix tracking issues that can elongate stars. Rather that astro surface (I may have to look at that), I use AstroSharp for sharpening. Sometimes I also look at what NeatImage noise reduction/sharpening can do. Then I'll normally finish up with GIMP if necessary because I'm more adept at using the "curves" stretching there than its equivalent in Siril. And I can also add text for object names.
Gfischer
Posts: 323
Joined: Thu Jun 22, 2023 4:20 pm

Re: 32-bit stack in Siril

#6

Post by Gfischer »

Sounds like a great work flow. I’m using an old i3 computer for both capture and processing (which I do concurrently). I tried graxpert but my system said no way. So I stay with Siril 1.2 and Starnet. I really need to look at a new computer 😀
Post Reply