Can plate solve and resync update alignment?

Anything that doesn't fit into any of the other forums
Post Reply
Albireo
Posts: 8
Joined: Thu Nov 09, 2023 1:13 pm

Can plate solve and resync update alignment?

#1

Post by Albireo »

I'm using a camera and a guide scope to use SharpCap's plate solve and resync feature to get really accurate gotos with my Celestron mount (using CPWI) for visual astronomy.

I used to use an AstroFi mount, and I am pretty sure that the mount would "learn" from SharpCap and update its alignment when I did plate solve and resync.

I'm now using a Nexstar 6SE, and it does not seem to be doing this.

If, for example, my north-level alignment is 8 degrees off, then the error reported by plate solve and resync will remain about 8 degrees off every time I do a goto in CWPI followed plate solve and resync. The plate solve and resync does work and gets the scope on target very accurately.

If I remember correctly, with the AstroFi mount the gotos done by CPWI would greatly improve in accuracy after the first plate solve and resync.

However, this is not happening with the Nexstar SE, and I'm wondering why.
User avatar
admin
Site Admin
Posts: 17584
Joined: Sat Feb 11, 2017 3:52 pm
Location: Vale of the White Horse, UK
Contact:

Re: Can plate solve and resync update alignment?

#2

Post by admin »

Hi,

the first thing to check is how you have set up the plate solving options in SharpCap - is it set to 'resync and re-goto target' or to 'offset mount position to center target'? The latter will not actually send a sync command to the mount, but will center the target, so in most cases the former option is preferred.

How the mount deals with the sync command when it receives it is not strictly defined by ASCOM, all the specification says is 'it should only be relied on to improve pointing for positions close to the position at which the sync is done'. That means that having done a sync if you move around in the vicinity of the sync then the mount should get things right, but moving further away may or may not be affected by the sync having happened, depending on how the ASCOM driver is implemented.

cheers,

Robin
Albireo
Posts: 8
Joined: Thu Nov 09, 2023 1:13 pm

Re: Can plate solve and resync update alignment?

#3

Post by Albireo »

It's set to "sync mount and re-center target".

I guess the Nexstar SE is just not doing the sync.
Albireo
Posts: 8
Joined: Thu Nov 09, 2023 1:13 pm

Re: Can plate solve and resync update alignment?

#4

Post by Albireo »

Last night I got the mount to update its model based on the results of plate solving even though it appears to ignore the syncs from SharpCap.

I went in the plate solving settings and set SharpCap to do "Offset the mount position to center the target" because syncing appeared to have no effect.

Then I did the north-level manual quick align in CPWI.

Then told CPWI to go to Capella. Then I clicked on Capella in the CPWI star map and clicked on "model" in the Capella dialog and it brought up another dialog with instructions to center the target and press "centered".

I then went to SharpCap and did a plate solve and sync (which I think was really "plate solve and Offset the mount position to center the target"). SharpCap said the mount was off by about 8 degrees.

I went back to CPWI and pressed the centered button. Now CPWI showed it had one reference point.

I repeated with a couple more targets, and from then on the syncs were accurate. Plate solving showed seeks in the same quadrant were off by about 0.05 degrees, and a seek all the way to the other side of they sky was off by 0.1 degrees.

I already had a plate solving solution in place (from using it with the AstroFi) when I got the Nexstar 6SE. I previously tried the standard three star alignment only once with the Nexstar 6SE (using SkyPortal on my tablet) and the results were terrible (I think 2 degrees off after centering the targets using an eyepiece that has an illuminated crosshair).

I figured the Nexstar SE mount was no more accurate with its gotos than the AstroFi and probably worse, and figured it would be useless without plate solving.

It's a pleasant surprise that it is accurate enough to be useful without using plate solving.
Post Reply