I try solar mosaic these days, when I try to use "Automatic Ailgnment" and click "Start Alignment " to start align, the sun image on screen seem doesn't move , then wait 20s , SC prompt:
"Move to RA=12:42:04.0,Dec=-04:32:35 would cause the mount to meridian flip - retry when target past meridian."
but it's about 9:20AM, not the time to need the meridian flip , so what's wrong ?
My mount is WD17s base on onstep. If I use "Guided Alignment" and complete the align, I can do solar mosaic . Maybe my mount not with accurate polar align, and the Guided Align not do so well accurate, sometime the mosaic have some misplacement. So I really want to have a try auto-align.
I attach the log , can you have a look what make the auto-align not work ?
problem with solar mosaic auto ailgn
problem with solar mosaic auto ailgn
- Attachments
-
- Log_2024-10-04T09_12_52-4904.log
- (759.73 KiB) Downloaded 168 times
-
- pic-2024-10-04 091915.jpg (498.78 KiB) Viewed 3772 times
- admin
- Site Admin
- Posts: 17574
- Joined: Sat Feb 11, 2017 3:52 pm
- Location: Vale of the White Horse, UK
- Contact:
Re: problem with solar mosaic auto ailgn
Hi,
thanks for posting - this is interesting...
SharpCap asks the ASCOM driver for the mount what side of pier would be used for the target co-ordinates, and I am guessing that your ASCOM driver either responds with 'Unknown' or it just has a bug in the code that does the calculation, so that it responds with the opposite side of the pier. SharpCap then works with that (incorrect information) and blocks the movement.
I will add code now that will check for a mount giving an 'Unknown' response when asked for this information, which might solve the problem. If not, we will have to do a log with 'Mount hardware communications' turned on to verify the responses from your ASCOM mount driver.
cheers,
Robin
thanks for posting - this is interesting...
SharpCap asks the ASCOM driver for the mount what side of pier would be used for the target co-ordinates, and I am guessing that your ASCOM driver either responds with 'Unknown' or it just has a bug in the code that does the calculation, so that it responds with the opposite side of the pier. SharpCap then works with that (incorrect information) and blocks the movement.
I will add code now that will check for a mount giving an 'Unknown' response when asked for this information, which might solve the problem. If not, we will have to do a log with 'Mount hardware communications' turned on to verify the responses from your ASCOM mount driver.
cheers,
Robin
Re: problem with solar mosaic auto ailgn
How can I check these ?
It's really strange when click "start alignment" , the sun didn't move .
It's really strange when click "start alignment" , the sun didn't move .
- admin
- Site Admin
- Posts: 17574
- Joined: Sat Feb 11, 2017 3:52 pm
- Location: Vale of the White Horse, UK
- Contact:
Re: problem with solar mosaic auto ailgn
Hi,
you would have to turn on the option to record 'Mount Hardware Communications' in the SharpCap logging settings before opening the camera or connecting to the mount. SharpCap will then add a lot of information to the log - you would then need to search the log for entries relating to 'DestinationSideOfPier' - those record SharpCap asking the ASCOM driver which side of pier a GOTO would end up on and also the response from the ASCOM driver.
Essentially, during the auto-align, SharpCap asks the mount about the destination side of pier before each GOTO movement, and will stop with the error you are seeing if any of them indicate that a meridian flip would happen in response to the GOTO.
cheers,
Robin
you would have to turn on the option to record 'Mount Hardware Communications' in the SharpCap logging settings before opening the camera or connecting to the mount. SharpCap will then add a lot of information to the log - you would then need to search the log for entries relating to 'DestinationSideOfPier' - those record SharpCap asking the ASCOM driver which side of pier a GOTO would end up on and also the response from the ASCOM driver.
Essentially, during the auto-align, SharpCap asks the mount about the destination side of pier before each GOTO movement, and will stop with the error you are seeing if any of them indicate that a meridian flip would happen in response to the GOTO.
cheers,
Robin
Re: problem with solar mosaic auto ailgn
log as files.
- Attachments
-
- Log_2024-10-06T09_28_13-16900.log
- (688.92 KiB) Downloaded 148 times
-
- screenshot-2024-10-06 093338.jpg (578.58 KiB) Viewed 3754 times
Re: problem with solar mosaic auto ailgn
any suggestion?
- admin
- Site Admin
- Posts: 17574
- Joined: Sat Feb 11, 2017 3:52 pm
- Location: Vale of the White Horse, UK
- Contact:
Re: problem with solar mosaic auto ailgn
Hi,
thanks for highlighting the relevant parts of the log - very helpful.
Sadly it looks like your mount ASCOM driver has a bug in the implementation of the 'DestinationSideOfPier' function - it's giving the opposite result to the current side of pier for small movements. I suppose it might equally be a bug in the reporting of the current side of pier, but the effect is the same.
It's worth checking that you have the latest version of the ASCOM driver installed, as it's just possible that the issue has been resolved in an updated version. You could also try reporting the issue to the developer of the OnStep ascom driver to see if they can fix it. The 'DestinationSideOfPier' functionality isn't really used much by software, so it's quite possible that a bug could lurk there for some time without being noticed.
If none of that helps, then I could try to add some sort of workaround or option to ignore the side of pier info to SharpCap.
thanks,
Robin
thanks for highlighting the relevant parts of the log - very helpful.
Sadly it looks like your mount ASCOM driver has a bug in the implementation of the 'DestinationSideOfPier' function - it's giving the opposite result to the current side of pier for small movements. I suppose it might equally be a bug in the reporting of the current side of pier, but the effect is the same.
It's worth checking that you have the latest version of the ASCOM driver installed, as it's just possible that the issue has been resolved in an updated version. You could also try reporting the issue to the developer of the OnStep ascom driver to see if they can fix it. The 'DestinationSideOfPier' functionality isn't really used much by software, so it's quite possible that a bug could lurk there for some time without being noticed.
If none of that helps, then I could try to add some sort of workaround or option to ignore the side of pier info to SharpCap.
thanks,
Robin
Re: problem with solar mosaic auto ailgn
I have install the most recently OnStep ASCOM driver 1.0.40, it is still the same so. I live in Northern Hemisphere, so I set sideofpier to 'BEST' or 'EAST' in OnStep setting menu.
I try to set sideofpier to 'WEST' in onstep setting menu at last weekend, the SharpCap solar mosaic auto-align work correctly now !
I don't known what's wrong at all. It seem that I live in Southern Hemisphere ? Anyway, I can use auto-align now
BTW, some settings in OnStep are different with other mount .
for example, in OnStep longitude West is + , East is -, but other mount use East as +. BeiJing TZ (GMT+8) must set 'UTC offset' to -8:00, but other mount use 'GMT+8' TZ.
I try to set sideofpier to 'WEST' in onstep setting menu at last weekend, the SharpCap solar mosaic auto-align work correctly now !
I don't known what's wrong at all. It seem that I live in Southern Hemisphere ? Anyway, I can use auto-align now
BTW, some settings in OnStep are different with other mount .
for example, in OnStep longitude West is + , East is -, but other mount use East as +. BeiJing TZ (GMT+8) must set 'UTC offset' to -8:00, but other mount use 'GMT+8' TZ.
- admin
- Site Admin
- Posts: 17574
- Joined: Sat Feb 11, 2017 3:52 pm
- Location: Vale of the White Horse, UK
- Contact:
Re: problem with solar mosaic auto ailgn
Hi,
well, I'm glad that you found a workaround that lets the solar mosaic auto-align run, but all of that is very odd! I've certainly not encountered anyone using +ve longitude to mean west of Greenwich before!
I can certainly understand though why the driver might get the information about the side of pier wrong - it's a complex concept, and the ASCOM documentation about it is long and difficult to follow.
cheers,
Robin
well, I'm glad that you found a workaround that lets the solar mosaic auto-align run, but all of that is very odd! I've certainly not encountered anyone using +ve longitude to mean west of Greenwich before!
I can certainly understand though why the driver might get the information about the side of pier wrong - it's a complex concept, and the ASCOM documentation about it is long and difficult to follow.
cheers,
Robin