Does polar align take atmospheric refaction into concideration
-
cyrille.de.brebisson
- Posts: 75
- Joined: Sun Oct 01, 2023 4:42 pm
Does polar align take atmospheric refaction into concideration
Hello,
Well, I guess most of everything in the title.
Yesterday, we tried doing a polar align on a scope with both a pole master and sharp cap, and they did not give the same values (around 1.5 arc minutes difference)
So we were wondering what detail could cause the 2 to disagree...
Thanks again for this great software,
Cyrille
Well, I guess most of everything in the title.
Yesterday, we tried doing a polar align on a scope with both a pole master and sharp cap, and they did not give the same values (around 1.5 arc minutes difference)
So we were wondering what detail could cause the 2 to disagree...
Thanks again for this great software,
Cyrille
-
kaymann
- Posts: 297
- Joined: Thu Jun 16, 2022 2:59 pm
- Location: https://azkayfes.blogspot.com/
Re: Does polar align take atmospheric refaction into concideration
Long backstory here. I did the same as you did because my plate solve was not producing good results. I too learned that PoleMaster was giving different results from SharpCap. What I did find is that my plate solving improved when I used SharpCap obtained polar alignment.
I am going to test SC vs PM vs NINA but I am going to predict SC and NINA both with beat PM.
I have some ideas as to why PM is not performing as well as SC, including:
I am going to test SC vs PM vs NINA but I am going to predict SC and NINA both with beat PM.
I have some ideas as to why PM is not performing as well as SC, including:
- lack of refraction correction in PM
Too many click here (which can be off center) in PM, which can compound errors.
PM Mount off center bracket or bracket tilt
Re: Does polar align take atmospheric refaction into concideration
Comparing PM, SC & NINA won’t prove much apart from which give the closest reading to each other.
Drift alignment is the more accurate so do that and the see how far off that alignment is for the others. Note drift alignment takes time and being mobile, I don’t have much time so I spend it on imaging if we ever get good weather again in my location.
(Report please out of curiosity)
I find using the polemaster camera in the sharpcap polar alignment the quickest.
PM camera doesn’t need focusing and is ready to go
You don’t need to be in NINA with stuff connected. Just jump into sharpcap when stars start to appear, align, close sharpcap and then finish setting up the rest of you gear.
(I’m mobile for imaging so setup every time.)
Drift alignment is the more accurate so do that and the see how far off that alignment is for the others. Note drift alignment takes time and being mobile, I don’t have much time so I spend it on imaging if we ever get good weather again in my location.
(Report please out of curiosity)
I find using the polemaster camera in the sharpcap polar alignment the quickest.
PM camera doesn’t need focusing and is ready to go
You don’t need to be in NINA with stuff connected. Just jump into sharpcap when stars start to appear, align, close sharpcap and then finish setting up the rest of you gear.
(I’m mobile for imaging so setup every time.)
-
cyrille.de.brebisson
- Posts: 75
- Joined: Sun Oct 01, 2023 4:42 pm
Re: Does polar align take atmospheric refaction into concideration
Hello,
This is a fixed post, so time is not an issue... We can spend a whole night getting it right if needed as it then won't have to move for a while.
Let us talk about drift alignment (I have never done it)...
Is there a way to take a 20mn exposure, look at drift and quantitatively infer from it what the polar alignement error is so as to correct it?
Is there a SW that can take a fits, with time, focal, pixel size, mount location and sky position and say: You have a polar error of ra*dec?
I am trying to avoid having to do things by "winging it"...
Thanks,
Cyrille
This is a fixed post, so time is not an issue... We can spend a whole night getting it right if needed as it then won't have to move for a while.
Let us talk about drift alignment (I have never done it)...
Is there a way to take a 20mn exposure, look at drift and quantitatively infer from it what the polar alignement error is so as to correct it?
Is there a SW that can take a fits, with time, focal, pixel size, mount location and sky position and say: You have a polar error of ra*dec?
I am trying to avoid having to do things by "winging it"...
Thanks,
Cyrille
- admin
- Site Admin
- Posts: 17574
- Joined: Sat Feb 11, 2017 3:52 pm
- Location: Vale of the White Horse, UK
- Contact:
Re: Does polar align take atmospheric refaction into concideration
Hi,
in theory, yes... The technique roughly works like this (the exact maths is left as an exercise to the reader!)
* Take an exposure with the scope pointing E or W, plate solve
* Wait 20 min (or move by 20min RA with absolutely no DEC movement - GOTO no good here, but rotate RA axis might be)
* Take another exposure, plate solve
The difference in Declination of the two plate solve positions is due to the polar misalignment in the N/S direction (at right angles to the E or W where we were measuring).
Take the angle that the RA axis rotated in the 20 minutes we waited = 20 minutes / 24 hours * 360 degrees = 5 degrees
Calculate the N/S polar alignment error given by NSError * sin(angle) = declination difference
Repeate with measurements either N or S of the pole to calculate the E/W polar alignment error. In theory no need to be E/W and N/S, could be any two directions at right angles, but that makes the maths harder...
cheers,
Robin
in theory, yes... The technique roughly works like this (the exact maths is left as an exercise to the reader!)
* Take an exposure with the scope pointing E or W, plate solve
* Wait 20 min (or move by 20min RA with absolutely no DEC movement - GOTO no good here, but rotate RA axis might be)
* Take another exposure, plate solve
The difference in Declination of the two plate solve positions is due to the polar misalignment in the N/S direction (at right angles to the E or W where we were measuring).
Take the angle that the RA axis rotated in the 20 minutes we waited = 20 minutes / 24 hours * 360 degrees = 5 degrees
Calculate the N/S polar alignment error given by NSError * sin(angle) = declination difference
Repeate with measurements either N or S of the pole to calculate the E/W polar alignment error. In theory no need to be E/W and N/S, could be any two directions at right angles, but that makes the maths harder...
cheers,
Robin
-
cyrille.de.brebisson
- Posts: 75
- Joined: Sun Oct 01, 2023 4:42 pm
Re: Does polar align take atmospheric refaction into concideration
Hello,
Thanks, makes sense and I will, as an exercise
double check the math!
And I am assuming that the same calculation can give the azimuth error...
One question however, Will this be affected by things like atmospheric refraction? as, 20 minutes later (or if I want to be more precise, 1h (in RA)) later, the object will be higher in the sky?
Thanks again,
Cyrille
Thanks, makes sense and I will, as an exercise
And I am assuming that the same calculation can give the azimuth error...
One question however, Will this be affected by things like atmospheric refraction? as, 20 minutes later (or if I want to be more precise, 1h (in RA)) later, the object will be higher in the sky?
Thanks again,
Cyrille
-
Jean-Francois
- Posts: 858
- Joined: Sun Oct 13, 2019 10:52 am
- Location: Germany
Re: Does polar align take atmospheric refaction into concideration
Hello,
If you want more information ... you can read the following pages: https://canburytech.net/DriftAlign/index.html
OK, nothing about the relative new method with a Plate Solve. But, you will have a lot of information about the atmosphere effects.
Regards,
Jean-Francois
If you want more information ... you can read the following pages: https://canburytech.net/DriftAlign/index.html
OK, nothing about the relative new method with a Plate Solve. But, you will have a lot of information about the atmosphere effects.
Regards,
Jean-Francois
-
cyrille.de.brebisson
- Posts: 75
- Joined: Sun Oct 01, 2023 4:42 pm
Re: Does polar align take atmospheric refaction into concideration
Hello,
Re-reading all the answers here... I realised that I did NOT get an answer to the original question!!!
Does SharpCap make use of refraction in the polar alignment process?
Once correctly aligned to TRUE/Physical north, my mount normally will correct for atmospheric refraction...
So I need to align to true, physical North, not "visual" north (I do not know the delta at latitude 45 between refracted and not refracted polaris)...
Thanks again,
Cyrille
Re-reading all the answers here... I realised that I did NOT get an answer to the original question!!!
Does SharpCap make use of refraction in the polar alignment process?
Once correctly aligned to TRUE/Physical north, my mount normally will correct for atmospheric refraction...
So I need to align to true, physical North, not "visual" north (I do not know the delta at latitude 45 between refracted and not refracted polaris)...
Thanks again,
Cyrille
-
Jean-Francois
- Posts: 858
- Joined: Sun Oct 13, 2019 10:52 am
- Location: Germany
Re: Does polar align take atmospheric refaction into concideration
Hello Cyrille,
A lot of professional astronomers had in the past the same question about the best alignment of the mount axis.
Real axis direction or the visible position ?
You mention that your mount will normally correct for atmospheric refraction ...
Do you mean for the GOTO position of the target ? or the tracking is active corrected during the observation ?
Only professional mount with direct drive motors on both axis and a full pointing model can do that.
Before looking the last arcseconds ... are you sure that your setup is stable at that level ?
You can do the following test: Perform the SharpCap Polar Alignment 2 times.
The first time with the telescope tube on the East side and then 90°, the second time with the tube on the West side and then 90°.
For your question ... you can "answer"yourself
Regards,
Jean-Francois
A lot of professional astronomers had in the past the same question about the best alignment of the mount axis.
Real axis direction or the visible position ?
You mention that your mount will normally correct for atmospheric refraction ...
Do you mean for the GOTO position of the target ? or the tracking is active corrected during the observation ?
Only professional mount with direct drive motors on both axis and a full pointing model can do that.
Before looking the last arcseconds ... are you sure that your setup is stable at that level ?
You can do the following test: Perform the SharpCap Polar Alignment 2 times.
The first time with the telescope tube on the East side and then 90°, the second time with the tube on the West side and then 90°.
For your question ... you can "answer"yourself
Jean-Francois
- admin
- Site Admin
- Posts: 17574
- Joined: Sat Feb 11, 2017 3:52 pm
- Location: Vale of the White Horse, UK
- Contact:
Re: Does polar align take atmospheric refaction into concideration
Hi,
yes, refraction is a tricky topic...
My thoughts are...
If the pole is low in the sky (low latitude) and you will be imaging high in the sky then you want to turn the option to correct for refraction on in SharpCap - that will align you with the *true* pole, not the refracted pole. Since the effects of refraction will be small where you are imaging nearer to the zenith, this will give best results
If, however, you intend to image near the pole, turn *off* the refraction correction and align to the refracted pole - the stars in that region will appear to rotate around the refracted pole, so this option would give best results in that scenario.
If you are polewards of 45 or so degrees latitude then the effect is probably small enough not to worry about too much.
cheers,
Robin
yes, refraction is a tricky topic...
My thoughts are...
If the pole is low in the sky (low latitude) and you will be imaging high in the sky then you want to turn the option to correct for refraction on in SharpCap - that will align you with the *true* pole, not the refracted pole. Since the effects of refraction will be small where you are imaging nearer to the zenith, this will give best results
If, however, you intend to image near the pole, turn *off* the refraction correction and align to the refracted pole - the stars in that region will appear to rotate around the refracted pole, so this option would give best results in that scenario.
If you are polewards of 45 or so degrees latitude then the effect is probably small enough not to worry about too much.
cheers,
Robin