Page 1 of 3

PA with a dobsonian

Posted: Tue May 11, 2021 4:10 pm
by Tiago Ferreira
is it possible? i can't rotate 90 degrees. precisely. should i do it more or less?

Re: PA with a dobsonian

Posted: Wed May 12, 2021 1:45 pm
by admin
Hi,

Polar alignment only makes sense if you are using an equatorial mount - Dobsonians are Alt/Az mounts, so do not need polar alignment (for completeness, some people mount Dobs on an equatorial platform, which would need PA).

cheers,

Robin

Re: PA with a dobsonian

Posted: Wed May 12, 2021 1:49 pm
by Tiago Ferreira
admin wrote: Wed May 12, 2021 1:45 pm Hi,

Polar alignment only makes sense if you are using an equatorial mount - Dobsonians are Alt/Az mounts, so do not need polar alignment (for completeness, some people mount Dobs on an equatorial platform, which would need PA).

cheers,

Robin
I have it on an Equatorial platform. And is drift aligned but i want to know if it's viable to use the sharpcap for it too.Thanks

Re: PA with a dobsonian

Posted: Wed May 12, 2021 2:08 pm
by admin
Hi,

Ah, OK.

Right, the amount of rotation is pretty much irrelevant - it can be anything from about 30 degrees up to about 150 and you should get decent results.

The instructions just say 90 because it is (a) the most accurate by a small amount and (b) nice and simple to explain.

cheers,

Robin

Re: PA with a dobsonian

Posted: Wed May 12, 2021 2:35 pm
by Tiago Ferreira
admin wrote: Wed May 12, 2021 2:08 pm Hi,

Ah, OK.

Right, the amount of rotation is pretty much irrelevant - it can be anything from about 30 degrees up to about 150 and you should get decent results.

The instructions just say 90 because it is (a) the most accurate by a small amount and (b) nice and simple to explain.

cheers,

Robin
As far as i understand an eq platform usually rotate 15º so that means that from the end (or start) to the middle of that arc, where it position at 90º, the rotation will be only around 7,5º.
Do you think it can work?
Should i try just those 7,5º or should i try rotate all the 15º arc to the 2nd step of sharpcap PA?
Sorry but i searched a lot everywhere for a long time and there is absolutely no info about this experiment anywhere with sharpcap and PA a dobsonian on Eq platform. So i want to try it (if viable). If it works i'll share the results.

Re: PA with a dobsonian

Posted: Wed May 12, 2021 2:57 pm
by admin
Hi,

SharpCap 4.0 has a 'reduced rotation' mode for star trackers - however this still requires a minimum 15 degree rotation currently, so from one side of the adjustment all the way to the other and hope... In theory that number could be reduced to (say) 12 or 13 degrees, but I worry about how the accuracy is affected...

cheers,

Robin

Re: PA with a dobsonian

Posted: Wed May 12, 2021 3:06 pm
by Tiago Ferreira
Ok, i will proceed with the experiment. I have my set up pretty well drift aligned and always precisely placed on the same position every night so it will be easy to verify if sharpcap PA can match my already drifted set up. Will see if this feature fit these kind of set ups.

Re: PA with a dobsonian

Posted: Sat Jun 19, 2021 10:01 am
by Tiago Ferreira
Until now the experiment has failed. At 2nd part it always fails because it ask me to rotate the telescope further and i can't.
Could be important to choose a certain region of the sky to try it with my limited set up rotation? Or would be the same no matter where i point to?

Re: PA with a dobsonian

Posted: Sat Jun 19, 2021 1:45 pm
by admin
Hi,

I am going to reduce the rotation limit to 13 degrees in SharpCap 4.0 in low rotation mode, also make it log the rotation so far more frequently at low angles, so we can see how far you are able to rotate. This will be in Monday's update.

cheers,

Robin

Re: PA with a dobsonian

Posted: Tue Jun 22, 2021 10:37 am
by Tiago Ferreira
admin wrote: Sat Jun 19, 2021 1:45 pm Hi,

I am going to reduce the rotation limit to 13 degrees in SharpCap 4.0 in low rotation mode, also make it log the rotation so far more frequently at low angles, so we can see how far you are able to rotate. This will be in Monday's update.

cheers,

Robin
The rotation reduction you've made has worked!
Now it does not ask to rotate further and just move on.
Unfortunately it was a mess of a night, with moon, wind and me bumping the 12" "cannon" in the dark so the results were suspicious. I'll keep trying.
I also asked for help to more dobsonian owners because i may do something wrong.
For example, should i do all the process with the equatorial platform tracking, right?
I track it at the end, sharpcap resolve, i rotate it (pull the shaft to the beginning) and sharpcap accept it and solve, but always tracking i suppose?