Page 1 of 1

Newtonian Mask

Posted: Tue Nov 10, 2020 2:19 pm
by oopfan
Throughout time and space, I've only owned refractors. In my opinion, refractors are great for lunar and planetary imaging, but I have also seen outstanding images taken by fast refractors, although they are pricey. Lately, I have become smitten by reflectors, although I do not own one (yet). One thing I like is the diffraction pattern produced by the secondary mirror assembly. So, until one day in the future when I decide to buy, I wanted to see if I could simulate it using my refractor. I watched YouTube videos where people use dental floss stretched across the dew shield, but I wasn't too happy with the results. So, I decided to create my own using my 3D printer.

The first attachment shows a 3D model of the profile of a secondary mirror and vanes, plus some imitation screws that add spice to the diffraction pattern. I created it using AutoDesk's Fusion 360. The next attachment shows the mask inside my flat-field device, something I call "The Flatinator." I built it two years ago from a concept I had. In the image, you can see the mask. It is held in there firmly by the surrounding structure, but there is still enough margin that I can rotate it to achieve any desired rotation angle.

I tested it two nights ago on the star, Almach, in Andromeda. It looks pretty spicy! Now I need to try it on a real target. Please see my upcoming posts in the Gallery for M34 and NGC 1664.

Brian
Newtonian Mask 3D Model.jpg
Newtonian Mask 3D Model.jpg (58.65 KiB) Viewed 9449 times
Newtonian Mask Flatinator.jpg
Newtonian Mask Flatinator.jpg (35.47 KiB) Viewed 9449 times
Almach using Newtonian Mask.jpg
Almach using Newtonian Mask.jpg (18.79 KiB) Viewed 9449 times

Re: Newtonian Mask

Posted: Tue Nov 10, 2020 6:51 pm
by admin
Hi Brian,

that looks like an interesting project - all the fun of Newt star spikes and none of the high maintenance normally required by anything with mirrors :)

Did you find/use the 'Maskulator' program to simulate the pattern that you get from the mask before making it?

cheers,

Robin

Re: Newtonian Mask

Posted: Tue Nov 10, 2020 7:41 pm
by oopfan
Robin,

I discovered that StarTools has a tool name "Synth". I talked about it briefly here:
viewtopic.php?f=16&t=3291

There are two steps involved:
1. Designing the "mask" with close to a dozen properties.
2. Applying the mask with a different set of controls.

It opened my eyes. I'll look into the Maskulator. Thanks!

Brian

Re: Newtonian Mask

Posted: Wed Aug 17, 2022 9:32 am
by sharpcapt
Hi
Anybody have a copy of the Maskulator that can be shared here?

I am going insane now, a 'popular' programme as Bahtinov Mask was and still is but they disappear from the internet 'somewhat' (I do not wish to speculate on why!).

Why is it everybody tend to post 'dead' links and not the actual .exe?

I am mean it is a 'free' program made for 'people' to share, right?
:shock:

Thanks

Re: Newtonian Mask

Posted: Wed Aug 17, 2022 9:36 am
by sharpcapt
Correction!

The link from web archive advertise everywhere, initially shows a Server Error.

Then I thought lets wait a few seconds more and I was right.

Download link comes out fine!

https://web.archive.org/web/20160312134 ... com/?p=376

Then click on Maskulator and 'wait' after you get (well I did!) a server error.

:D

Re: Newtonian Mask

Posted: Wed Aug 17, 2022 12:15 pm
by admin
Hi,

glad you found the download. I believe that the guy who wrote Maskulator sadly died some years ago (at a rather young age). In due course his domains expired and his web site(s) have vanished.

cheers,

Robin